Best diet? Consumer Reports weighs in on Jenny Craig, Weight Watchers, Atkins and more

Ranks & Geography

Ediets vs nutrisystem???
Truck drivers go the extra mile for a boy's birthday surprise. I say try Jenny out. Typical weight loss is around 2 to 5 lbs. We looked at two plans from eDiets - one that offers support alone, and another with meal delivery. Girl surprised by Drake at Chicago hospital gets heart transplant. There are thousands and thousands of healthy Weight Watchers recipes on the web, and they are things that both you and your family can eat. When I gain weight back on, it isn't the diet's fault.

Popular on CBS News

The Best Ways to Lose 20 Pounds

However, the advantage disappeared over the long term. How much can you expect to lose? Figure on 8 to 13 pounds during the two- week kick-start phase, then 1 to 2 pounds a week thereafter. It doesn't cost much, but you don't get as much support as with Weight Watchers or eDiets.

The Zone diet is mostly meat, fruits, and vegetables. You eat three meals per day plus two Zone protein-powder snacks. A study of people in the Journal of American Medical Association found the Zone diet helped people achieve modest weight loss after one year, comparable with those on the Atkins , Weight Watchers and Ornish diets, and improved cardiac risk factors. Premium-priced Jenny Craig lets you order its heart-healthy, nutritionally balanced packaged food by phone and pick it up at a Jenny Craig center or have it delivered through Jenny Direct.

You eat three Jenny Craig meals plus a snack per day, and supplement with fruit, vegetables and dairy. Once a week, you get a weigh-in and pep talk with a consultant - who is not a dietician and who earns commissions from selling you products. There's also round-the-clock phone support. Jenny Craig has a good track record for short-term weight loss up to one year.

In a UC San Diego clinical trial of dieters funded by Jenny Craig , Jenny Craig clients lost 11 percent of their initial weight after 12 months, compared with 3 percent weight loss by those who were dieting on their own. The "doctor-designed" Bistro M.

The price is a cut above the competition, too. The plan tries to help you avoid a weight-loss stall out by varying the daily calorie intake between 1, and 1, By eating a little more some days and a little less on others, you'll supposedly prevent your body from becoming used to the same number of calories every day.

While no university studies support the theory that varying caloric intake aids weight loss, the high quality of the food and the relatively large portion sizes have been praised by Health magazine, Dr. Phil and The New York Times. Some plan users have complained of a lack of choices and menu flexibility compared to other plans, but a company spokesman says they offer more than entrees and can make substitutions to accommodate allergies and food preferences.

It's a reasonable price for well-made food with slightly faster average weight loss than with Jenny Craig. This meal-delivery service, endorsed by Marie Osmond and Dan Marino, emphasizes foods with a low glycemic index. The underlying premise is that controlling blood sugar levels leads to weight loss. The heat-and-eat prepared meals and snacks contain roughly 55 percent "good" carbs, 25 percent protein, and 20 percent fats; like Jenny Craig, you add fruits, vegetables and dairy.

Support is available through phone counseling and online chat rooms. There's plenty of research showing that following a diet of 1, to 1, calories a day, such as Nutrisystem, can cause weight loss. For example, a study by the Obesity Research Center at St. Luke's Roosevelt Hospital in New York found that postmenopausal women who followed a 1,calorie plan for 16 weeks lost an average of 21 pounds.

For a meal-delivery diet system, Nutrisystem is more economical than Jenny Craig. Although today's program is not as stringent as the original liquid fast Medifast launched decades ago, the low-fat, relatively low-carb plan is designed to bring about rapid weight loss by coaxing your body into a "fat-burning state" known as ketosis. The 70 meal replacement choices include shakes, bars, soups, pudding, oatmeal, chili, pretzel sticks, cheese puffs, and scrambled eggs. If you can stick with it, a diet of 1, calories a day can certainly induce rapid weight loss.

A common concern with such low-calorie diets is that you'll quickly regain the weight, but in a small clinical trial recently published in the journal Experimental Biology , after 10 months, only about one in five people regained all the weight they had lost. Choose this more extreme plan only if quick weight loss is your priority. Within hours of posting a seven-second video of their son learning to walk, Whitney and Adam Dinkel were flooded with messages. The small town of Wenatchee, Washington, is at the center of a virtual gold rush — whether residents like it or not.

Share Tweet Reddit Flipboard Email. Cost per pound of weight loss: It's economical and has a proven track record. In the Zone Delivery Cost: No, unless you're looking for white-glove service. Yes - it's got reasonably priced meal delivery and in-person support. This affordable dietitian-designed program will save you time and money.

After you join the site, you will enter your height, weight, goal weight and eating preferences and whether or not you're looking for an exercise plan as well as an eating plan. After entering your initial personal info, customers are then taken to a page which displays their BMI body mass index and two program options to choose from: You can change from one diet plan to another i. This plan acts as a kind of automated nutritionist. After inputting your personal data and health goals, the eDiets Vitabot Plan formulates an eating plan fitting your needs.

It includes ideas and recipes from a database that contain thousands of options. The Vitabot Plan creates menus for each individual member by focusing on varying nutritional and health categories as determined by the member: Depending on the diet program you choose, you'll be eating a wide variety of wholesome nutritious options:.

The Vitabot Plan's foods are dependent on each member's preferences. Every member has access to a large number of daily meal plans, depending on the program they sign up for. Daily meal plans can also be customized by the dieter to best suit their food preferences. Shopping lists are also available, which the dieter can quickly update on any device and print at home. Fitness logs with recommended exercises can also be accessed. For those curious people who would like to compare the current eDiets program to the old one, we have listed an overview of the old eDiets program below.

This information talks about the old version of eDiets, which is now longer available: The company offers 7-day and 5-day meal delivery programs as well as online membership. The online eDiets membership plan supports dozens of commercial diet programs such as Atkins. Customers enter their height, weight, goals, and preferences.

The study, which was not funded by any commercial weight-loss plan, is published in the April 7 issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine. Gudzune and several of her co-authors reported receiving support from the U. The obesity crisis prompted the study, as doctors weigh the various options on hand to help their patients lose weight , Gudzune said. Two-thirds of adults in the United States are overweight or obese, increasing their risk for high blood pressure , heart disease and type 2 diabetes , the study authors pointed out.

Nutrisystem has about 14 percent of the market, while Jenny Craig has about 13 percent, the study said. While these plans are popular, doctors don't have a lot of information regarding which show real and sustained results, Gudzune said.

Gudzune and her colleagues reviewed 4, studies. They were only able to find randomized, controlled trials considered the "gold-standard" for medical research for 11 of the 32 major weight-loss programs. Of those 11, only Weight Watchers and Jenny Craig had gone through studies showing that people not only lost weight but kept it off for at least a year, researchers found. Weight Watchers helped participants sustain almost a 3 percent greater weight loss at 12 months than people in a control group who just received information about healthy eating.

Secondary links